Senior Home Review
Home›Browse›Wisconsin›Milwaukee›Saint Johns On the Lake
Nursing homeFAID #13222

Saint Johns On the Lake

1858 N PROSPECT AVE, MILWAUKEE, WI, 53202
(414) 272-2022
27 licensed beds
★★★★★4/5CMS Five-Star overall3/5 health inspections5/5 staffing3/5 quality measuresSource: CMS Care Compare

Generate this report

Primary Report$79Advanced Report$99
Delivered within 24–48 hours

Public record summary

What we can show you for free.
Bed capacity
27
State license
0017912
CMS facility ID
525539
Care type
Nursing home
Facility name
Saint Johns On the Lake
Street address
1858 N PROSPECT AVE
City / state / ZIP
Milwaukee, WI 53202
Phone
(414) 272-2022
State license #
0017912

About this facility — Saint Johns On the Lake

Saint Johns On the Lake is a Medicare/Medicaid-certified skilled nursing facility in Milwaukee, Wisconsin. It is licensed for 27 beds — well below the median for skilled nursing facilities in Wisconsin (65 beds).

It is one of 336 senior care facilities in Milwaukee and 323 skilled nursing facilities across Wisconsin. Families comparing options should weigh inspection history, ownership record, and litigation — not just the tour — before deciding.

Federal inspectors have cited Saint Johns On the Lake 35 times across 7 inspections in the last three years, including 2 food-safety citations; no federal fines are on record. Every citation is listed, dated, and graded in the inspection record below.

This listing draws on federal CMS Nursing Home Compare records, and was last updated on August 31, 2026. Background reports are compiled from primary sources — state inspection files, federal CMS data, corporate registrations, and court records — at the time of order.

Facility background

What the public record shows.

Ownership & operator

Operator / owner
Saint Johns Communities Inc
Ownership type
Non profit - Church related
Administrator
Meighan Bentz

Registered owners & officers

Anderson, Cassandra
Additional disclosable party — since 2022
Anderson, Renee
Officer · Additional disclosable party — since 2011
Armbruster, Kathy
Additional disclosable party — since 2016
Arndt, Betty
Additional disclosable party — since 2022
Beal, Polly
Additional disclosable party — since 2014
Beckley Milner, Diane
Additional disclosable party — since 2018
Behavioral Solutions Inc
Additional disclosable party — since 2024
Brighton Hospice Wisconsin Llc
Additional disclosable party — since 2023
Burke, Erin
Additional disclosable party — since 2019
Butler, Helene
Additional disclosable party — since 1999
Coburn, Matthew
Additional disclosable party — since 2021
Community Foot and Ankle Clinic Inc
Additional disclosable party — since 2019
Coppernoll, Lee
Additional disclosable party — since 2018
Davis Clinical Consulting
Additional disclosable party — since 2024
Dietitians On Demand Corporate Solutions, Llc
Additional disclosable party — since 2022
Eager, David
Additional disclosable party — since 2023
Exum-pryor, Lakeshia
Additional disclosable party — since 2018
Fry, William
Additional disclosable party — since 2024
Geszvain, Melissa
Additional disclosable party — since 2019
Guardian Pharmacy of Madison, Llc
Additional disclosable party — since 2023
Gunter, Matthew
Additional disclosable party — since 2024
Hearing Care At Home Llc
Additional disclosable party — since 2022
Henderson, Antonio
Additional disclosable party — since 2020
Hildebrand, Kirsten
Additional disclosable party — since 2023
Hometown Hospice & Homecare Inc
Additional disclosable party — since 2014
Integrated Therapy Managment Partners, Llc
Additional disclosable party — since 2024
Kare Technologies Llc
Additional disclosable party — since 2023
Kelnhofer, Alan
Additional disclosable party — since 2025
Legacy Hospice Cares Llc
Additional disclosable party — since 2022
Lemminger, Dan
Officer · Additional disclosable party — since 2011
Loyd, Matthew
Operational control · Additional disclosable party — since 2021
Luther, Anne
Additional disclosable party — since 2007
Madison Medical Affiliates Inc
Additional disclosable party — since 2013
Mass, Omar
Additional disclosable party — since 2022
Moon, Judith
Additional disclosable party — since 2015
Patrinos, Daniel
Additional disclosable party — since 2023
Petitt, Dorothy
Operational control · Additional disclosable party — since 2021
Preferred Dentistry Associates, Llc
Additional disclosable party — since 2024
Saint John's Communities, Inc.
Direct owner · Operational control · Additional disclosable party — since 1994
Saltness, Rachel
Operational control · Additional disclosable party — since 2024
Schreiner, Richard
Additional disclosable party — since 2024
The Medical College of Wisconsin Inc
Operational control · Additional disclosable party — since 2024
Us Bank National Association
Mortgage holder — since 2015
Whiteside, Cazmer
Additional disclosable party — since 2024

Regulatory standing

Licensed / certified since
1994-07-01
CMS overall rating
4 of 5 stars
Health deficiencies
7 at the last standard inspection
Federal fines
None on record
Last standard inspection
2025-06-03
Nurse staffing
5.3 hours per resident per day

Cost & payer profile (FY2023 cost report)

Average billed charges
$628 per day (≈ $19,090/month). Private-pay prices typically track billed charges; Medicare and Medicaid pay set rates.
Payer mix (resident days)
0% Medicaid · 10% Medicare · 90% private/other
Occupancy
73% (fiscal year 2023)
Vs. state median
54% above the WI median of $407/day — full state cost breakdown

Services & coverage

Licensed beds
27
Licensed as
RCAC
Medicare
Accepted
Medicaid
Accepted
Reported monthly rate range
$7,755 – $9,585
Compiled from CMS Nursing Home Compare; owners/officers from the CMS Ownership dataset; cost & occupancy from the facility's own CMS cost report · last verified 2026-08-31. Facilities can submit a correction.

Inspection record

Every citation, dated and graded.

Kitchen & food safety

Federal surveyors inspect the kitchen at every standard visit. This facility has 2 food-safety citations on its three-year record — flagged below among the inspections.
2026-04-01Health inspectionComplaint-triggered1 citation
F-0610
D · No harm foundFrom a complaint
Respond appropriately to all alleged violations.
Corrected 2026-04-30
2025-06-03Health inspection6 citations
F-0605
D · No harm found
Prevent the use of unnecessary psychotropic medications or use medications that may restrain a resident's ability to function.
Corrected 2025-07-07
F-0645
D · No harm found
PASARR screening for Mental disorders or Intellectual Disabilities
Corrected 2025-07-07
F-0812
F · No harm foundFood safety
Procure food from sources approved or considered satisfactory and store, prepare, distribute and serve food in accordance with professional standards.
Corrected 2025-08-29
F-0880
F · No harm found
Provide and implement an infection prevention and control program.
Corrected 2025-08-29
F-0881
D · No harm found
Implement a program that monitors antibiotic use.
Corrected 2025-07-03
F-0908
F · No harm found
Keep all essential equipment working safely.
Corrected 2025-08-29
5 earlier / fire-safety inspections (28 citations)
2024-04-24Health inspection1 citation
F-0880
F · No harm found
Provide and implement an infection prevention and control program.
Corrected 2024-05-24
2023-02-21Health inspection6 citations
F-0684
D · No harm found
Provide appropriate treatment and care according to orders, resident’s preferences and goals.
Corrected 2023-03-27
F-0686
G · Actual harm
Provide appropriate pressure ulcer care and prevent new ulcers from developing.
Corrected 2023-04-17
F-0755
D · No harm found
Provide pharmaceutical services to meet the needs of each resident and employ or obtain the services of a licensed pharmacist.
Corrected 2023-03-27
F-0757
D · No harm found
Ensure each resident’s drug regimen must be free from unnecessary drugs.
Corrected 2023-03-27
F-0812
E · No harm foundFood safety
Procure food from sources approved or considered satisfactory and store, prepare, distribute and serve food in accordance with professional standards.
Corrected 2023-03-27
F-0880
D · No harm found
Provide and implement an infection prevention and control program.
Corrected 2023-03-27
2025-06-03Fire-safety inspection8 citations
E-0039
F · No harm found
Conduct testing and exercise requirements.
Corrected 2025-07-25
K-0321
E · No harm found
Ensure that special areas are constructed so that walls can resist fire for one hour or have an approved fire extinguishing system.
Corrected 2025-07-02
K-0324
E · No harm found
Provide properly protected cooking facilities.
Corrected 2025-07-02
K-0541
D · No harm found
Install properly constructed and protected linen or trash chutes.
Corrected 2025-06-25
K-0712
C · No harm found
Have simulated fire drills held at unexpected times.
Corrected 2025-06-26
K-0761
D · No harm found
To conduct inspection, testing and maintenance of fire doors by qualified individuals.
Corrected 2025-07-09
K-0918
F · No harm found
Have generator or other power source capable of supplying service within 10 seconds.
Corrected 2025-07-09
K-0923
D · No harm found
Have proper medical gas storage and administration areas.
Corrected 2025-06-25
2024-04-24Fire-safety inspection5 citations
K-0132
F · No harm found
Meet requirements for outpatient facilities located next to inpatient facilities separated by fire resistive construction.
Corrected 2024-05-24
K-0341
D · No harm found
Install a fire alarm system that can be heard throughout the facility.
Corrected 2024-05-24
K-0353
D · No harm found
Inspect, test, and maintain automatic sprinkler systems.
Corrected 2024-05-14
K-0712
C · No harm found
Have simulated fire drills held at unexpected times.
Corrected 2024-05-24
K-0918
F · No harm found
Have generator or other power source capable of supplying service within 10 seconds.
Corrected 2024-05-24
2023-02-21Fire-safety inspection8 citations
K-0132
E · No harm found
Meet requirements for outpatient facilities located next to inpatient facilities separated by fire resistive construction.
Corrected 2023-03-22
K-0291
F · No harm found
Install emergency lighting that can last at least 1 1/2 hours.
Corrected 2023-03-22
K-0311
E · No harm found
Have an enclosure around a vertical opening shaft.
Corrected 2023-03-22
K-0324
E · No harm found
Provide properly protected cooking facilities.
Corrected 2023-03-22
K-0341
F · No harm found
Install a fire alarm system that can be heard throughout the facility.
Corrected 2023-03-22
K-0353
F · No harm found
Inspect, test, and maintain automatic sprinkler systems.
Corrected 2023-03-22
K-0781
E · No harm found
Have restrictions on the use of portable space heaters.
Corrected 2023-03-22
K-0918
F · No harm found
Have generator or other power source capable of supplying service within 10 seconds.
Corrected 2023-03-22
Citations and penalties from the CMS Provider Data Catalog (three-year survey window, refreshed monthly). Severity codes follow the federal scope/severity grid; “Immediate jeopardy” is the most serious grade CMS issues. CCN 525539.

Inside your report

What unlocks when you order.

Ownership & corporate history

Primary tier
Prior operators & transfers
Corporate network & affiliates
,
Owners' other facilities
· · 2 more

Inspection citations — last 5 years

Locked
The 35 citations above are shown free. The report takes each one and explains it in plain English — what the tag requires, how serious the scope/severity grade really is, whether it recurred across surveys — plus the five-year pattern a single inspection can't show.

Civil & criminal lawsuits

Advanced tier only
Active civil suits
#
Federal dockets
CDC infection data
Unlock the full file
Citations, owner history, lawsuits — decoded into one PDF.
$79$99 Advanced

Original records

Sources we pull for this facility.
Source
CMS Nursing Home Compare
data.cms.gov Provider Data Catalog
Last verified 2026-08-31
Source
Secretary of State filings
Entity & officer search
Pulled when a report is ordered
Source
PACER federal dockets
pacer.uscourts.gov
Pulled when a report is ordered